ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22

ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 222020/09/28

It's been reviewed here and with a 22 round magazine it deserves a spot. To clean the other two Luger knockoffs, you have either a button to push or a pin to rotate, and thats pretty much it. If youre looking for something a little more classic but just as fun, the Heritage Rough Rider is a strong contender. The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. I don't shoot it very much any more, but when I do, I have Fun!. Some 22 LR ammo with slower-burning powder works extremely well in rifles, but not so well in short-barrel pistols. Then (yep!) How about the M&P22? Where the rubber meets the road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and little else. I love my Glock's but the S&W has never failed with any type of ammo. The price is high, worth every penny, but high. 5) The SR-22 is made here in the US. It also fires every kind & brand of ammo that you feed it. Said another way, your goals and preferences might not look like my goals and preferences. It also had failed to fire in the past in other good guns. Click below for a FREE LESSON! The common gripe about safeties of this nature is that the thumb must awkwardly flick or push it up and forward to the fire position, and then semi-easily swipe it down to the safe position. Very light weight, reliable, and just plain super fun. This is what I'm hearing across the board, ty!!! I might be looking for a different set of characteristics than you are in a specific handgun for a specific purpose, or in anything else for that matter. You lost credibility here! The new sig p322 has a high mag capacity and that was about the only thing I liked about. The heavy bull barrel makes recoil management a cinch. For me, thats a big benefit. But when a gun does that well over time, it can serve as a benchmark against which to test newer products, which in this case is the Ruger SR22PB Model 03600, $399. leeman357 1.78K subscribers Subscribe 467 41K views 3 years ago Ruger SR22 vs SW M&P 22 Compact - Battle of the Compact .22 Caliber. It is one of the pricier guns on this list, but youre getting one of the best .22 LR revolvers around. We tried a final test on both guns. Check out our full review of the SW22 here. Ergonomics on the FN 502 are great, and the ambidextrous controls win it some favor among the left-handed crew. For a street price of around $450, you get three 16-round mags, a red dot-ready slide, a muzzle compensator, and a very nice trigger. Height 4.9 inches 4.5 inches. As a kid, a .22 rifle was what Dad taught you with. But now, Im seeing more and more .22 LR versions on the shelf at my local gun store. Type your new password and hit button below to confirm it. If we were picky, wed have the rear notch a tad narrower, but as it was it was fast to use. I did have some jams initially with it, but as I have put more and more rounds through it I have not had a problem. It is my favorite range gun when I just want to have a bit of fun. A mechanical safety is ambidextrous and located rearmost on the frame in approximately the same position as a 1911, but curiously the safety is awkwardly pushed upward to place the pistol on fire and down to place the pistol on safe, contrary to the typical function of safeties in this location. The second issue is that the trigger spring wears out rapidly. This is similar to the takedown for the PPK, but the recoil spring is not around the barrel here, its on a small rod that falls out when you remove the slide. Overall, both guns ran well, and would certainly meet my definition for reliable even in a defensive context so long as you stoke them with quality ammunition that you had previously tested for certain function. The Walthers double action pull, while heavy, is smooth and a glitch-free with only some noticeable stacking near the very end of the triggers travel. Just a great overall gun. (If Ruger or Walther decided to do it, we suspect a great many fans of James Bond would buy the guns just for the fact that they look like the famous PPK. Both are entirely functional, and have only minor gripes associated with them. I have fired several hunderd rounds of CCI standard and CCI mini mags. This pistol fired flawlessly, with no jams, no stove pipes and the accuracy is just what you would expect, not match grade, but close. The texture of the Rugers grip leaves a little bit to be desired for those who like to workout hard with their guns, with only a few sparse rows of a treaded texture on the very corners of the front strap and continuing around partially onto the side panels. Second, the sights on the SR22 are superior to the P22. Barrel length: 3.5 inches. Its a delight to the eye, very busy yet business-like in its look. I never shoot it anymore because I'm sick of it. The Buckmark is hands down a favorite of mine and the grandkids. The legendary Walther P22 was noted for its awesome trigger, clean design, and tactical styling. I just bought some yesterday. I would say it is the best little 22 I have ever shot. It does feel like its worth a mention that some reviewers experienced cracking on the G44 slide. In previous models, reinstalling the frame was relatively easy, but then you had to try and finagle the bolt-stop pin back in, and it was a nightmare fit to make a grown man weep in frustration. But both guns magazines were easy to manage. And I believe that differentiation began with the Hi-Standards - which were offered in different grip angles. We looked at the Ruger Mark IV, so check out our review here. Whats your favorite .22 LR handgun? However, for fun like busting tin cans, these guns are great. Cycles everything you feed it. In a February 2006 test of four handguns, our Idaho staff called the Walther P22 22 LR No. One of the easiest slides to rack, good crisp trigger, and I prefer the grip angle much more than the luger pattern models you apparently prefer. But, internally, there are significant differences especially in the operation of the trigger and the safety. The Walther has a significant advantage in its nicer trigger and grip texture, where the sights on the Ruger are slightly better but it has a nasty DA trigger and is slippery. Thats the weak point of this design, because you need a tool in the form of a slave rod to capture the spring before you can reassemble the gun. Barrel length is 3 inches while the pistol has an overall length of just under 6 inches, with an overall height just a hair under 5 inches. Thanks again, I have several safe queens, some carries, and now have a half dozen .22's just so I can shoot to keep in practice. I love my Heritage, it falls inline with the points you mentioned. Incredible!! The rear sight is adjustable for windage with elevation being adjusted by replacing the front sight with one of several included various heights. I don't like recommending stuff I haven't used. Windage was easy to correct with the screw-adjustable rear sight. A conventional picatinny-style rail is molded into the dust cover of the pistol and will accept compact lights and lasers. Or if youre lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. Read our review of the Heritage Rough Rider here or watch the full video review below. The double tap mentality is opposite, and actually is faster. guns & So keep reading if youve been considering a .22 LR handgun. Thoughts? Walther P22 is fun to shoot but I wouldn't rely on it in a CCW capacity. . .22LR handguns are a lot of fun to shoot. Width 1.29inches 1.1inches. Who cares what your daughter shoots? I may earn a small part of the sale from links to any products or services on this site. We thought the single-action trigger was excellent on the P22. My first pistol to shoot and now own is a Ruger Mark I, Standard with the 4 3/4 in barrel. Maybe, depending on your use for the gun. A common observation made about these two pistols is they are basically the same gun with different brands, with the Walther being the original and the Ruger being the copy. Move it down to the safe position and the hammer moves back a touch if its down, but doesnt drop if its cocked. The Buckmark requires you to remove the slide bridge, which is annoying enough by itself. Hope this is readable. The Walther is not made by Walther, it's junk and best avoided. Ive got one Ive had almost 40 years( damn Im old!) The SW-22 Victory is another Luger-inspired gun. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. palmettostatearmory.com 299.99 View Deal Walther Arms P22Q 22 Lr 3.42" 10Rd Pistol. These guns are not tack drivers. A slight press with hand pressure on a proper-size punch got out the rear grips retaining pin, and we easily installed the flatter housing. Get proficient on YOUR time. The sight picture was excellent, and had three white dots. Its rugged monolithic design means that itll almost certainly outlive you and possibly your children and grandchildren as well if its cared for. Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. I know Lone Wolf had them for $250 a while back. We found the magazine release to be annoyingly hard to use. The Walther put this fine ammo into ten-shot groups of 2.6 inches and 2.8 inches respectively. Walther makes it easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal. When two people who have set out to make objective determinations based on their subjective needs bring their findings together this often results in the locking of horns and considerable consternation in comment sections around the internet. It is because of this I looked at your list here. We finally put it in location and rapped it with a stick, and in it went. As a comparison test, we fired one of our 45 autos loaded with Cor-Bons PowRball, and put five into a ragged one-inch hole at the same 15-yard range. I have many favorites! Ruger SR22 Vs Walther P22 . In a broader sense these are also general-purpose pistols; more or less equally at home in a self-defense role or a recreational plinking or target shooting role, and both are configured in such a way to be instantly comfortable for the vast majority of semi-auto pistol shooters today. A few differences that might make a shooters decision one way or the other is the configuration of the safety and the grip options. Hmm, shoulda, coulda, day late and a dollar short. Our Team Said: We ended up being not so fond of the Ruger. Finally, I consider availability and aftermarket support. Curious as to why no mention of the Taurus TX22? This is a difficult trick to manage for any handgun, because differing ammo selections, test conditions, individual pistol variations, and matchups can magnify the flaws found in any product, making it hard to get a top grade again and again. I have several 22 LR pistols Ruger Mark 0, Mk III 22/45, and a SR-22. Best bang for your buck in my humble opinion, and I've had no issues with reliability. The m9 in .22 is a great choice! One may compare, contrast and analyze any two guns, or any number of guns that have any set of features against each other in quest of reaching a conclusion. I've yet to see any serious criticism of the TX22, other than "it's a taurus". The double-action pull was good enough that we could hold the gun on target easily until the gun fired, but we did not attempt to make groups DA. We found that inserting the slave rod through the hole in the front of the slide was the easiest. My first pistol to shoot was the S&W Victory, then the Browning Buckmark, and now a Ruger Mark IV 22/45 Lite. I was able to buy the unit which has the extra cylinder for 22 mag. Yeah for the .22. The G44 offers a classic Glock lookseriously, it looks just like a G19, with similar dimensions too. I have the Walther P22Q. It may be possible to do so without that tool, but we could not do it. I own the Heritage Rough Rider and love it. Taurus nailed it for the competition. In general, you want to use some fairly stout loads to ensure good function, as it is possible to go with lighter and lighter loads, especially match loads, and see regular malfunctions. You can lower the hammer by grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and pressing the trigger. As good or better than Ruger Mark III, and S&W (both the later have red dots). YES CHILDREN LEARNING TO SHOOT. Had some misfeed issues with the Ruger, about as much as I did with the S&W and the Browning. The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. MSRP: $439-479 (depending on the model). Best shooting Semi auto for me was a PPK I was allowed to try. But the feeling of the grip is fantastic. From a purely practical standpoint they differ very little in operation or disassembly and you might fairly say that the Ruger cribbed quite a few notes from the Walther, but it is not a complete copy. So if the Ruger is going to be carried for self-defense, one can get a leg up on getting the gun into gear by carrying it with the safety off in double action mode, but the specter of inadvertent safety re-engagement will always be looming, and is an eventuality that must be trained for. I shot ammo that came from a ziplock bag several different bullet types and manufacturers present and I didn't have an issue with the Victory. The SR22s trigger put us off. The safety has no decocker function, but the gun can be placed on-safe and the trigger still be used to release the hammer so that it may manually be lowered under control with assurance that a mishap will not result in a negligent discharge. Both the ergonomics, trigger, and reliability beat the hell out of the P22 & SR22. It seems that G&G is not compatible to Word. The details, below, are from Wikipedia. The cons are many and I would not recommend this unless you want the best and can afford finding one. Walther's P22 Target was the only test gun with a polymer frame. I second the M&P 22lr. It brings a 10+1 capacity, and while it doesnt have a lot of aftermarket support, it doesnt need a whole lot. and it's very well priced. If you ever do a followup to this article "6 Best .22LR Pistols/Handguns [Hands-On]: Tiny & Awesome" I might suggest the Glock 44. We thought it was an ideal fun gun, one wed take in the backpack and not even know its there. Then, in the May 2010 issue, we wrote, Our Team Said: The unanimous decision was that the P22 was the top performer in our tests.. sportsmans.com 369.99 View Deal Walther P22 Q For Sale Walther P22Q 8 more deals from guns.com 275.99 View Deal Walther P22Q .22 Lr 3.4" Pistol, Black -. Ruger SR22 WaltherP22. My question for you is what are your thoughts on some of the conversion kits for .22LR - (Specifically the Advantage Arms conversion for the Glock 19/23). Accuracy was so poor we did not record it. As they were in sight of their home, a car with four Mossad agents pulled up beside them. Sights are your choice. While some may roll their eyes at the need for a .22 caliber Glock, the PPT team sees the benefits. They loved the "cowboy" gun. I cant sing the praises of the GP-100 enough. Using bulk ammo too. Again the same thing happened with the Ruger. A polymer frame is topped by an aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel. I dont question the lack of the TX22 in your review as a Taurus fanboy. I'm a big fan of the Walther P-22, though I prefer the Target model with its longer barrel and subsequent longer Sight Radius, it does make a big difference in your groups, and the added weight of the "compensator" tames the already fairly tame recoil. One of my favorite firearms. The same thing happened with the Ruger. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, the 1911. I liked its looks and it felt good in the hand. What would have impressed us mightily is if Ruger (or Walther) had attempted to copy the original Walther PPK for the 22LR, and brought it off nicely at a good sale price. Thank you. But there are a host of options available from Smith and others. Hope it was done here even thou not mentioned. Per the ATF.gov website, that means, 22 LR Semiautos: Walthers P22 Versus the Similar Ruger SR22, 9mm Luger Personal Defense Ammunition Testing, Ruger American Long-Range Target (LRT) 8378 22 LR, New Shooters Guide: The Best Gun For Home Defense Isnt a. While one of us was in Alaska running a trap line, the handgun was kept warm in a shoulder holster. There are even competitions you can enter with rimfire firearms like the .22 LR that are loads of fun. My trigger is about 3+ pounds in double action with no creep. A variety of lights can be put on there, but we fail to see the need for a light on a 22 handgun. A laser sight there might make some sense for those with compromised vision. You're probably an FBI troll. Thanks! With our No. There were three white dots. I am, however, open to some suggestions since I haven't the hand strength and will need my grandson to teach me how to shoot this. Probably at Ruger, waiting for its recall parts to be fixed. A rail for mounting of lights and lasers is also beneath the barrel on the dust cover. It is a tack driver. You got that right Ricardo. OTHRS WITHTAKE DOWN SCREW A REAL BUMMER. Itll certainly make a good training tool for youngins and new shooters, but fun is what this gun is all about. Otherwise, I have turned my M4 22/45 Light into a race gun with just shy of 1100 bucks via mostly Tandem Kross and Volquartsen less the racker which I went elsewhere for that juts out one side (left) for much more confidence than trying to put my finger through a ring in a fraction of a second or the cone type requiring perfect grasp and a 45 degree forward angled muzzle break that I compared to both TK's modeks back to back. The Walther P22 is full of tactile surprises. I have a Browning Buckmark target model which is very accurate, but a bit too clunky for my wife to shoot. I know this one is an antique - but I the I am a proud owner of a High Standard Model 107 Supermatic Citation Military 5 1/2 " barrel - with the original box - and it is pretty BA. you a link to reset your password. So long as the gun is reliable, delivers sufficient accuracy and enables the shooter to produce that accuracy with relative ease, a gun gets a pass from me. I would agree. You can't say that for the Walther, which is notorious for being finicky as to the ammo it will fire & cycle. I enjoy my Heritage SA six-shooter, Glock 19 and 26 and Canik. I believe they were released in 2011 for the 100 year anniversary of the 1911. Either the buttons need to be longer or the frame needs to be relieved to make it easier to change mags. Each seems to have a con that counters the other. The controls are simple and straightforward. Although the gun can be carried cocked and locked, its not a convenient safety for that purpose. I take my TX to the range, along with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines and have a BALL. A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. Unfortunately it didn't work for me. The Ruger SR22 is definitely a better gun but it is vastly inferior to Ruger's MK and 22/45 series of pistols - especially the trigger. The first, Rugers SR22, is one of the newer rimfire offerings from a company that is virtually synonymous with rimfire handguns thanks to their legendary Mark I through IV pistols. However, these grip bumps were not on the front of the front strap, where much of the grip pressure is placed if you know how to shoot a handgun. I'd say for a cheaper option that's not on this list, Bersa is definitely a good place to look. Just a fun and comfortable pistol to shoot and work with. The rear site is both windage and elevation screw adjustable and the blade is reversible for dots or flat black. Go figure. The windage was slick and handy, we found, and adjusted with relative ease. We think anyone in need of a fine little .22 pistol that works every time and doesnt bust the bank need look no farther than the short-barrel P22. We haven't bought the part yet because we have many other guns to shoot but I hope to fix this . The M&P 22 Compact features a threaded barrel while the SR22 Ruger features a standard and threaded barrel for their various models. Other than that it has been flawless! Keep them coming! I find that it isn't reliable enough, too many misfires and fte's for my comfort. Its one of the most reliable, especially with mixed ammo. S&W M&P 22 vs Walther P22 vs Ruger SR22 SoMD_Gen4 Mar 29, 2016 The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast Member Benefits: No ad networks! Six of the 15-member Mossad team (the shooters got away) were arrested by Norwegian police and sentenced to jail time from one to five years, but in 1975 all were returned to Israel. We are investigating reports of a knuckledragging mouthbreather with a firearm. This is like reviewing .22LR long guns and omiting Anschutz!!! Will look forward to your future articles. I haven't had any FTL or stovepipe problems. That, according to Bill Ruger. PS - your statement 'good for a woman," is sexest. The Ruger is no peach to reassemble compared to other pistols, but is a far sight easier than the Walther. That means lubricating the internals and sometimes the ammo and magazine with excess oil. Ruger Sr22 22 Long Rifle 3.5In Tungstun Cerakote/Black. I am a new gun owner and bought a ISSC M22 (i bought it on a whim and did no research) it shoots well enough but the ONLY ammo it takes without jamming is CCI Mini mags. Check out the Best .22 LR Rifles and Best .22 LR Ammo. I always start new shooters out on .22 lr, also go to the .22 when I get persons that were given bad training with wrong weapons and advice. A big plus is you can buy the regular model, and then upgrade to the target merely by purchasing the Target Kit. I just read the review of the glock 44. The Ruger has an ambidextrous button that will be instantly familiar to American shooters, but it is a little bit stiff in operation. The Ruger had no problems with feed or function with good ammo. Responsible gun owners understand what you wrote.

Barbara Siegel Saperstein, Articles R