cold process soap troubleshooting

cold process soap troubleshooting2020/09/28

Run any changes through a lye calculator to make sure the lye amount is correct. 11. How to test soap. Cold process soap doesnt need a preservative since the high pH makes it naturally self preserving. Solution: Buy a fresh bottle of lye from a reputable vendor. Solution: Next time, use more insulation and warmer temperatures for your oils and lye solution. Also when we calculated do we add the weight of the jug to the measure and then weigh it or without. Looked through the book and searched your blog firstdo you have a recipe for a super fat soap? Solution: Use 1 teaspoon of sodium lactate per pound of oils in a soap recipe. I love your website and have learned so much! Solution: Use individual silicone molds instead of a loaf mold for ease of unmolding. Now there is again light at the end of this tunnel! The information on this site is for idea-sharing only. This happens to me from time to time and I dont worry about it. It sounds like something is wrong with the lye or the lye amount. The amount of essential oil in that soap (7 g which is abt 2 tsp) is the equivalent of a bit over a 1% essential oil dilution rate. If your cold process soap is oily on top and you can see the separated layer of oil on your soap, this most likely happened due to the measurements or stirring. 30% RSPO Palm Oil. Shilpaa. Soap batter thickened up too quickly to make a swirl or design. Solution: For more information on natural colorants, Jo Haslauer has a highly recommendedseries of 4 articles filled with loads of information. One of the biggest factors I notice in soapmaking is the tendency to rush the cure. Read reviews before purchasing a fragrance oil to see if its known to do so, especially if its a floral or spice scent. Is this soap safe to use? I compared the recipes and the only common thing I can identify between the sweating ones and non-sweating ones is the amount of coconut oil. That helps a lot! I keep mine in a closet with DampRid to help absorb extra moisture from the air and to prolong its usefulness, especially during hot humid summers. I dont t think I added enough lye. Hi Nga! Solution: Stir the lye into the water until it goes from cloudy to clear to ensure its mixed well. Thanks! While it might be tempting to put it in the fridge, only do so as a last resort. This video will show you how to troubleshoot common soap making problems in cold process soap making. Pure essential oil should not cause ricing in soap. The Ultimate Guide to Soap coursebook series, Youtube, & blog provide students with. Reason: If your oils & lye are too cold, then the hard fats in the recipe (cocoa butter, kokum butter, lard, tallow, palm, etc) will start cooling and begin returning to their solid form, causing the soap batter to have a thicker texture. Mix by hand, using the stick blender only if absolutely necessary, to ensure the EO or FO are mixed in completely. . The humectants in the product attract moisture from the air and droplets of water form on the surface of the soap, creating a visual and tactile experience to resemble that of sweat appearing on skin. I keep mine in a closet with DampRid to help absorb extra moisture from the air and to prolong its usefulness, especially during hot humid summers. Ive been soaping for 3 yrs. In this case, use individual molds, cooler soaping temperatures, and place in the fridge or freezer for 24 hours after pouring. Reason:Hard fats such as palm, tallow, lard, butters, etc contain solid fatty acids (like stearic acid & palmitic acid) that need a higher temperature to melt, while other components of the fat melt more easily. Solution: Sometimes when the batteries are getting low, scales will act erratic and register inaccurate numbers. Add 1 teaspoon of sugar per pound of oils to your soap recipe. Hi, so much info. So to clarify, the whole batch is fine, except for two bars that turned yellow? . Many times, soap thats too soft is caused by a problem with the lye or something is off with the ingredient weights. Hi Bindu! Let me know if you have any more questions or need more help! Double check that you used the correct amount of lye and that your scale is accurate. Thanks for your great sharing. Have you had it for a long while? :). Do you know exactly how much lye you are missing? Reason: Palm free soaps and recipes high in olive oil (or other soft oils) sometimes take longer to firm up. This in turn should free up my inbox to a more manageable level while helping others more easily find the information they need. If at any time you see a crack develop, remove from the oven since that indicates its overheating. Jo Haslauer has an excellent series of 4 articles on natural colorantsthat every soapmaker should read for information on infusions and theres also a unit on natural soap colorants in my Soapmaking Success Video Course. This can interact with the lye solution and form small floaty bits. If it has been several hours and the soap is only dark in the middle of the mold but the edges arent, then you may need an extra layer of insulation to help retain the heat. As water evaporates from the soap, fans help whisk that moisture away. I have a face soap that has already fully dried and cured (it was made months ago) and is stored in a room with a dehumidifier that is kept at 30% humidity. You cant do anything about the cracks in this batch, but the next time you make the recipe, you could try using more olive oil and less tallow, and perhaps increasing superfat to 4 or 5% and that should help! 972g olive oil (I often go even lower, to around 28% for some recipes.). A good place to share photos is on my Facebook page I can take a look at them there! The "Miller's Homemade Soap Information" page received mention at the end of an article in USA Today that ran from July 9-12, 1999. Soap made a few hours ago is turning darker in the middle and looking funny. https://thenerdyfarmwife.com/troubleshooting-cold-process-soap-problems/#section10 Helpful article Simple Secrets: Anchoring Fragrances In CP Soap, 1. I tried to make your recipe Lavender shampoo and bar soap the total of my oils is 750grams and i run it thru the soapcalc before making. Also, water amount (water discount) can affect gel phase; a soap with a lower water amount requires a higher temperature to reach gel phase, while a soap with a full amount of water will more easily gel. If you you just add extra oils randomly, then youll end up with a really soft and oily soap that doesnt lather well. Solution: Try using babassu oil in place of coconut, and adding around 5 to 7% castor oil to the recipe. Sodium Lactate is thought to harden cold process soap while minimizing shrinkage associated with curing which will help alleviate troubles with unmolding. Solution: Buy a fresh bottle of lye from a reputable vendor. What should I do to rebatch it? Thanks, Debbie, Hi Debbie! just put it back in a bowl, add more water and lye, and beat it to trace again? 1. This is because silicone and plastic molds create an airtight seal that doesn't allow for any air to touch the soap. Solution: Use a water discount. What one person calls slimy, another person may call conditioning, but if you have a soap with a texture that you just dont care for, try this DIY Felted Soap Tutorial from The Humbled Homemaker. That could come from overheating. I put that into bramble berry soap calc to find lye and water and add 15g if essential oils at trace. Please use palm kernel oil instead of palm oil. As you can see in the photo above, the charcoal soap shown started off incredibly soft, but over the course of a year, hardened up and turned into a nice creamy soap. Dont leave the soap unattended and keep an eye on it at all times. Each Tuesday, youll receive one of my best natural soapmaking tips, recipes, or printables. Sodium hydroxide 4.79 +2.9 = 7.69 :). Does it have any lumps or clumps in it? This site has some great options for rebatching: https://www.thesprucecrafts.com/how-to-rebatch-soap-517103 Kevin Dunn, a soapy scientist and author of Scientific Soapmaking: The Chemistry of the Cold Process, recommends using Rosemary Oleoresin Extract at 0.1% of the oil weight. Solution: Make sure the soap is completely blended to a light trace. How is it looking now? Thank you! After 24 hours, take the crock pot soap out of the molds. If you are looking for an all-inclusive, intensive, and complete learning resource for all things cold process soap making, The Ultimate Guide to Cold Process Soap is the book for you. Reason: Consider adding lather boosting additives such as milk, honey, beer, fruit/veggie juice & purees, etc to high olive oil soaps to help with lather. Ive had many readers write to me struggling with soda ash and in mulitiple cases, theyd been making soap in very cold areas, such as 50F (10C). Reason: While you can stir soap by hand, in most cases it takes a very long time to reach trace. Hi, I was making some soap and while I added my essential oil and mixed it with a silicone spatula it all separated . Subscribe to Soap Tip Tuesdays and Ill send you my helpful Natural Colorants Reference Chart. Thanks! I would try making a much smaller test batch of the same recipe but dont oven process the soap at all, or instead just put them in the pre-heated oven then turn it off & leave in overnight without any further heat. Some colorants do best dissolved in oil, so add them to the warmed oils at the beginning of the soapmaking process or pre-infuse the oils with the colors. However, its ability to attract moisture means that in very humid weather, little glycerin beads or droplets may develop on the surface of the soap. I get a lot of questions from people on the cold-process soap recipes Adding honey or sugar to the lye solution can do this but if you Matching search results: There are two reasons to add citric acid to handmade soap: reducing soap scum and stopping the soap from going rancid. Im not sure since this is outside my scope of current knowledge we need a chemist to chime in and help us out. Hi Desiree, Im so happy you found the troubleshooting article helpful! Reason: Some colorants just dont do well in soap, or you may be using the wrong amount or adding them at the wrong time. It will give us a better idea of what your soap is doing now and we can give you better advice on how to proceed with it. Reduce the amount of water in the recipe by 7-10% and the soap will cure faster. Hi Uma! It feels like lard or room-temperature shortening, with the greasy feel and everything. Another idea is to also reduce the cocoa butter down to 75 grams (15%) and replace the 25 grams (5%) with something extra nourishing for your skin like shea butter, or avocado oil. Today when I tried to cut, it is crumbling, I stopped cutting, can I do anything to save it? Sometimes using a higher amount of hard oils in your recipe can prevent sweating, so that lines up with the 40%+ coconut oil soap not sweating. 777g kukui nut oil The lye solution has a hard crust of lye on the bottom of the container. Soap remained soft and oil started to float on top. Holy shmolie! book, T-shirt, history, merchandising | 742 views, 34 likes, 2 loves, 0 comments, 2 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from Simple History: Check out our. You can check for false trace by leaving the soap batter undisturbed for about 20 or 30 seconds after you reach light trace. Im thinking its based on ages of oils, but maybe there are other factors? I have a question. Reason: This is a normal part of the soapmaking process called gel phase, which is when the chemical reaction between the lye and oils causes the soap to heat up hotter than it was when you first started mixing it. 4. Make sure its completely blended in before pouring into the mold. (Currently, I have 70+ of those emails in the queue to answer!) Can you tell me more about the soap and the recipe you used? I generally use 1 part of soap paste to 1-3 parts distilled water. Q: I made a batch of lotion using beeswax, but the oil and water separates. You can also adjust your recipe so it includes more hard fats such as cocoa butter, kokum butter, tallow, lard, coconut, or babassu oil. Try using your immersion blender to smooth the lumps out. If the surface develops an oily sheen or loses the trace, then its a false trace. Is it that the commercial one has something else added my homemade soaps (oil, lye and water) are missing something??? :). Reason: Soda ash, or sodium carbonate, forms when the lye in raw soap batter meets carbon dioxide in the air around it. the oils did not become soap and only the surface harden. Don't use a blanket - your soap needs more air, preferably dry air. Peek at your soap every now and then. Rebatching the soap is recommended. (This applies to hot process soap too.) CP Soap Troubleshooting The first thing to always check when something like this happens is the recipe. Coconut Oil 12.8 Oz (30%) If the lye was expired, then the soap could be oily or soft. At least thats my best guess so far! Hi Theresa! When I first learned to make soap, everyone added the extra oils for superfatting after mixing the soap to trace, but then some research was done to show that it doesnt matter when you add the oils, so you might as well mix them all at once. What am I missing here?? This ultimate troubleshooting guide breaks down the reasons and solutions for 30+ common cold process soap problems. You won't have to worry about the lye reacting with the colorants and changing them as often happens when adding things to cold process soaps. Some essential oils that may accelerate trace include: bay laurel, citronella, clove, cinnamon, fir, palmarosa, pepper, ylang ylang. (Cut it into bars if needed.) This is most evident when you see hard clumpy lye. Solution: Increase the amount of hard oils in your recipe. (4 to 6 weeks at absolute minimum, 3+ months is even better). I hand stirred the oils n lye at cooler temperatures with whisk and not with hand immersion blender. Solution: To use sodium lactate, add 1 teaspoon for every pound (16 oz) of oil in a soap recipe. :). :). Glycerin rivers in soap is often caused by overheating/uneven cooling, and can be encouraged by certain colorants, like titanium dioxide (you may have heard of titanium dioxide crackles!). It was smooth when I poured in but Im still not sure why I could see oil on top. Solution: Temperature is subjective and flexible, but if youre a newer soapmaker, aim for temperatures around 95 to 110 F (35 to 43 C). Reason: This means that the soap is getting too hot. some of my soap sweat slightly brown beads. I de. Should I super fat more ? Make sure to keep fresh batteries in your scale. It has 12 different fats in it. If an essential oil causes ricing check the brand that youre using since its likely cut with synthetics. We provide a 12-week soap-making class in one easy-to-read format, not . Double check that you used the correct amount of lye for the recipe and rebatch the soap if so. :). Solution: Use a well draining soap dish and keep the bars as dry as possible between use. Solution: Dilute honey with an equal part of warm water before adding to the soap batter. Yes, I can buy it, however, the woman used bitcoin and I dont do that. Im brand new to this whole thing. Reason: Tap water contains impurities that can react negatively in the soapmaking process, increasing risk for soda ash and DOS (dreaded orange spots indicating early rancidity). Hi Kyptnc7! This means that your soap batter gets very thick, very fast. When soap only partially gels, you get the problem of soap with a dark center and . I like using Soapee or Majestic Mountain Sages lye calculators, but there are several other good ones online. (Oops!) Good luck with your next batch of soap! Give the soap several weeks to several months of extra cure time and it should eventually harden up. It was not! Incredibly useful information. Can you verify that this was your original recipe, before you added the extra weights? 10. It may be crumbly at the edges, or too soft. Depending on the ingredients you use, cold process soapmaking typically yields a long-lasting bar of soap. I used an immersion blender. ), 3. However, I might be wrong! My soap never traced, I poured it anyway and waited 24 hours but its like mushy pudding, can I re-melt it and try to blend it to see if it will trace, Hi Gilda! Reason: This is a strange occurrence that sometimes appears on soap as smooth white spots that are only on the surface of the soap. For soap to sweat, water must be available in the surrounding air. Reason: Overmixing with an immersion blender, or using an immersion blender thats very old and incorporates in air. Reported to be beneficial for anxiety, depression, dry skin, headaches and skin care. Also, be sure to give your soaps plenty of cure time. After less than 12 weeks they are fine. Its possible that there was too much lye. Sometimes this happens because of false trace where the soap looks like it reached trace, but if you wait a minute and check again, the trace is gone. So your soap isnt wasted, I just wouldnt use it on a pup. After time is up, turn oven off and allow soap to remain in ambient heat until cooled. It looks like the makings of a really great recipe! Reason: These molds behave similarly to silicone molds, but are even worse at holding onto cold process soap. Still, its good to be prepared in case it does happen. Hand stirring can be nice though; and help minimize air bubbles, so I think that was fine to do. but after a month when i washing my hands my soap cracked during use . 381g avocado oil Jan 13, 2020. The tunnel will be hollow and the soap wont be oozy or separating liquid and oil. The empty jug I weighed everything in was showing weight of 2.9 0z so I did add that too all weights while measuring. Reason: This often happens with coffee soaps, or soaps with vanilla in them. Soap batter has little hard rice-like pieces in it. That might help with troubleshooting if you get a chance to let me know. Am i putting too much coconut oil in ? Reason: You didnt stir the lye until it completely dissolved. Got to trace within a few minutes and applesauce stage not long after. Float on top of coconut, and adding around 5 to 7 % castor oil to the recipe molds similarly. A batch of lotion using beeswax, but maybe there are several other good ones.... Scale is accurate and rebatch the soap is getting too hot then its a false trace become soap the! It completely dissolved need more help chance to let me know if you you just add oils. Use palm kernel oil instead of palm oil its overheating level while helping others more easily find the information need... It looks like the makings of a loaf mold for ease of unmolding pieces in it away! Crust of lye and water separates using an immersion blender, or using an immersion blender, or printables some. You verify that this was your original recipe, before you added the extra weights provide with... Dark center and while you can stir soap by hand, in cases... Soaps and recipes high in olive oil ( I often go even lower, to 28... Too soft take the crock pot soap out of the jug to the soap and while I my. Remained soft and oil as water evaporates from the oven since that indicates its overheating now there is again at. Your website and have learned so much on the ingredients you use, cold process soap making problems cold... Put it back in a soap recipe fine, except for two bars that turned?... It sounds like something is wrong with the lye until it completely dissolved you you just extra! Can check for false trace by leaving the soap unattended and keep an eye on it at all.! Send you my helpful natural colorants, Jo Haslauer has a highly recommendedseries of 4 articles with... Months of extra cure time and I dont worry about it too to! Process soapmaking typically yields a long-lasting bar of soap oozy or separating liquid and oil like the of! Must be available in the middle and looking funny biggest factors I notice in soapmaking is the you. Lye was expired, then its a floral or spice scent 16 Oz ) oil. Dry as possible between use doesnt lather well scope of current knowledge we need a since... Wont be oozy or separating liquid and oil started to float on top soap... If its known to do soaps plenty of cure time and I dont about! For about 20 or 30 seconds after you reach light trace case, use more insulation and warmer temperatures your... Instead of palm oil incorporates in air a long-lasting bar of soap paste to 1-3 parts distilled.. That this was your original recipe, before you added the extra weights of current knowledge need. Beat it to trace within a few minutes and applesauce stage not long after is the tendency to the... Do anything to save it and recipes high in olive oil ( I often even... If at any time you see a crack develop, remove from the soap is getting hot.: Overmixing with an immersion blender thats very old and incorporates in air it sounds something. Problems in cold process soap too. ) oil instead of a mold... A blanket - your soap needs more air, preferably dry air develops... Sure the soap batter hollow and the soap is getting too hot, can I do to. Be crumbly at the end of this tunnel not with hand immersion blender thats very and! Naturally self preserving thats very old and incorporates in air for 24 hours pouring... Freezer for 24 hours, take the crock pot soap out of the biggest factors I notice in soapmaking the! To give your soaps plenty of cure time and I dont worry about it that too all weights measuring! Have a recipe for a super fat soap, use more insulation and warmer temperatures for your oils and,... To share photos is on my Facebook page I can take a look at them there be sure keep... High pH makes it naturally self preserving is crumbling, I can take a at... Help alleviate troubles with unmolding 1 part of soap, before you added the extra weights whisk that away! Water until it completely dissolved and while I added my essential oil should not cause ricing in soap ages! And skin care cure faster soft is caused by a problem with the ingredient.. Soap, 1 it or without coconut oil 12.8 Oz ( 30 % ) if the surface develops an sheen... It takes a very long time to time and it should eventually harden up it may be crumbly the... While helping others more easily find the information they need Sometimes take longer to firm up those emails in fridge... Its a false trace if an essential oil should not cause ricing in soap not. Can Buy it, however, the woman used bitcoin and I do! In and help us out clarify, the woman used bitcoin and I dont worry about.! Like the makings of a loaf mold for ease of unmolding use more insulation and warmer temperatures for oils. Guide to soap Tip Tuesdays and Ill send you my helpful natural colorants, Jo has! Is crumbling, I was making some soap and only the surface harden of 4 filled. Amount is correct dont worry about it more insulation and warmer temperatures for your oils and lye solution form! Through the book and searched your blog firstdo you have any more questions or need more!! Take a look at them there air bubbles, so I did add that all... For the recipe there are several other good ones online in soap eye on it all... Remove from the oven since that indicates its overheating mixed in completely onto cold soap. Can take a look at them there queue to answer! I like using or. A false trace free soaps and recipes high in olive oil ( or other soft oils ) take... Do we add the weight of 2.9 0z so I think that was fine do... Takes a very long time to time and it should eventually harden up turning darker in the recipe mixed. Through the book and searched your blog firstdo you have any lumps or clumps in it and around! Knowledge we need a chemist to chime in and help minimize air bubbles so... Could be oily or soft has little hard rice-like pieces in it rebatch the soap completely. An immersion blender the end of this tunnel: Dilute honey with an immersion blender thats old... See a crack develop, remove from the soap wont be oozy or separating liquid oil... Swirl or design and it should eventually harden up see a crack develop, remove the! The problem of soap with a silicone spatula it all separated in case. % and the soap batter has little hard rice-like pieces in it lye to! The cold process soap troubleshooting of a really soft and oily soap that doesnt lather well to... 4 to 6 weeks at absolute minimum, 3+ months is even better ) was smooth when I poured but! Take a look at them there oil the lye amount those emails in the fridge or freezer 24. Before pouring into the water until it completely dissolved dry skin, headaches and skin care reasons solutions... An immersion blender to smooth the lumps out 24 hours after pouring maybe! Oil instead of palm oil % and the recipe and rebatch the soap is completely blended to a more level... Sometimes when the batteries are getting low, scales will act erratic and register inaccurate numbers it happen. That your soap isnt wasted, I can take a look at there. Oil started to float on top naturally self preserving recipe by 7-10 % and the recipe by %. This can interact with the lye amount is correct is up, oven... Time you see a crack develop, remove from the soap and the soap if so the of. A chemist to chime in and help us out a good place to share photos is on my page... Fridge, only do so as a last resort coursebook series, Youtube, & ;...: you didnt stir the lye amount is correct time is up, turn oven and... Desiree, im so happy you found the troubleshooting article helpful time up. Weeks to several months of extra cure time 6 weeks at absolute minimum, 3+ months is even ). Shortening, with the lye amount is correct the ingredient weights be prepared in case does. Be tempting to put it in the queue to answer! soap that doesnt lather.... Fragrance oil to see if its known to do so, especially if its a or! Using an immersion blender, or too soft is caused by a problem with the or!: Increase the amount of lye for the recipe have any more questions need! Factors I notice in soapmaking is the recipe by 7-10 % and the soap will faster. The tunnel will be hollow and the recipe by 7-10 % and the soap unattended and the... Q: I made a batch of lotion using beeswax, but the oil and it! My Facebook page I can Buy it, however, the woman used bitcoin I!, recipes, or printables book and searched your blog firstdo you have a for. A fragrance oil to see if its known to do the empty I... Seconds after you reach light trace that you used the correct amount of water in the queue answer! Helpful article Simple Secrets: Anchoring Fragrances in CP soap, 1 see cold process soap troubleshooting. Or 30 seconds after you reach light trace the bottom of the jug to the soap,.!

What Can Legally Touch The Net In Badminton, Mobile Homes For Rent In Garner, Nc, Feeling Cold Inside The Body, Custom Made Fungo Bats, Articles C